google-site-verification: googled975c1a1ea3733fa.html

Layer 3

 

Custom-Designed Employee Work Schedules

 

clock-circular-outline 8:00am - 5:00pm (Central Time Zone), Mon-Fri  

Blog

12-Hour Shift Schedules with No Overtime
July 3rd, 2013 at 10:37 am   starstarstarstarstar      

I've written several articles about 12-hour shift schedules in 24/7 operations. Here are links to the most popular ones:

  1. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/12-Hour_Shifts
     
  2. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=12-hour-shifts-in-smaller-companies
     
  3. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=matching-12-hour-shifts-to-your-workload-distribution
     
  4. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=covering-absences-on-a-12-hour-shift-schedule

  5. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=are-12-hour-shifts-too-long
     

I also sell 2 packages with 10 different options: one with only 12-hour fixed shifts and another with only 12-hour rotating shifts. You can read more about this here:  Schedule Examples

 

Most 12-hour shift schedules for 24/7 coverage use 4 crews. When you divide the hours in a week (168) by 4 crews, you get a average of 42 hours/week. With 12-hour shifts, this will require half the work weeks to be 36 hours (three 12-hour shifts) and half to be 48 hours (four 12-hour shifts). 

In many organizations, especially public agencies, avoiding overtime is a high priority. They view overtime as evil or an unnecessary expense. I have repeatedly tried to argue the fallacy of this belief, yet I continue to get requests for 12-hour schedules with no overtime in them. Here are 2 articles on this topic:

  1. http://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Overtime_Issues
  2. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=why-eliminating-overtime-in-24-7-schedules-can-be-costly

Reducing the hours of work to 40 or less a week will result in gaps in the coverage and will require additional personnel to fill the gaps. In most cases, this is more expensive than simply keeping overtime in the schedule. In addition to higher costs, this will also require other sacrifices as seen in the following four approaches to eliminating overtime in 12-hour schedules for 24/7 coverage. 

 

Here is a key to the symbols used in the schedules below:


D12 = 12-hour day shift

N12 = 12-hour night shift

d8 = 8-hour day shift

n8 = 8-hour night shift

d4 = 4-hour day shift

a4 = 4-hour afternoon shift

e4 = 4-hour evening shift

n4 = 4-hour night shift


Here is how the schedules work. When the schedule first starts, the crews are assigned to specific weeks in the cycle. Crew A is assigned to start in Week 1, Crew B is assigned to start in Week 2, and so on. At the end of each week, the crews rotate down to the next week in the cycle. Crew A moves to Week 2, Crew B moves to Week 3, etc. When a crew completes the last week, they rotate up to Week 1. 

 

 

1. Eliminate the 48-hour work weeks. This sounds simple enough. Just change all the 48-hour work weeks to 36 hours by eliminating one of the shifts. To maintain the same coverage, this will require 5 crews (a 25% increase in headcount), rotating shifts, and a 4-hour pay cut for all employees. (Note that with fixed shifts, this would require 6 crews). There will also be one shift with double coverage (in the example below, it's the Friday day shift). Here's one example of a 5-crew schedule:

 

Crew / Week Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
A / Week 1 - - - - D12 D12 D12     36
B / Week 2 D12 - - D12 D12 - -     36
C / Week 3 - D12 D12 - - - N12     36
D / Week 4 N12 - - - N12 N12 -     36
E / Week 5 - N12 N12 N12 - - -     36
               Average

    36

 


2. Include an 8-hour shift. If you devote one day a week to 8-hour shifts and give one of the three 8-hour shifts to employees who are outside the group (e.g., part-time employees), the remaining four crews would average 40 hours a week. You would have to use a 12-hour work pattern in which the 36-hour weeks and 48-hour weeks are staggered and you would have to be able to average the work hours over a 2-week period (most companies can't do this because of overtime laws). In the sample shown below, the 8-hour afternoon shift on Wednesday would have to be given to employees who are not part of the four crews. That uncovered shift is not shown in the table below.


 

  Crew / Week  Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
  A / Week 1   - D12 d8 - - D12 D12     44
  B / Week 2   D12 - - D12 D12 - -     36
  C / Week 3   - N12 n8 - - N12 N12     44
  D / Week 4   N12 - - N12 N12 - -     36
              Average     40


3. Include a 4-hour shift. If you devote one day a week to 4-hour shifts and give two 4-hour shifts (or one 8-hour shift) to employees who are outside the group, the remaining four crews would average 40 hours a week. This does not require the averaging of pay over a 2-week period or a pattern with staggered 36 and 48-hour weeks. In the sample shown below, there is an 8-hour gap in coverage on Wednesday that would have to be given to part-time employees or someone outside the four crews. That uncovered shift is not shown in the table below.

 


  Crew / Week  Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
  A / Week 1  - D12 d4 - - D12 D12     40
  B / Week 2  D12 - a4 D12 D12 - -     40
  C / Week 3  - N12 n4 - - N12 N12     40
  D / Week 4  N12 - e4 N12 N12 - -     40
              Average     40

 

4. Reduce the work days to 11.5 hours. If you include a 30-minute unpaid meal break in the 12-hour shift, you only have to pay employees for 11.5 hours. You would have to adopt a 12-hour shift pattern in which the 48-hour weeks and 36-hour weeks were staggered. This won't completely eliminate the overtime, and you would have to be able to average the work hours over a 2-week period. An example is shown below:

 

  Crew / Week  Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
  A / Week 1  - D11.5 D11.5 - - D11.5 D11.5     46
  B / Week 2  D11.5 - - D11.5 D11.5 - -     34.5
  C / Week 3  - N11.5 N11.5 - - N11.5 N11.5     46
  D / Week 4  N11.5 - - N11.5 N11.5 - -     34.5
              Average     40.25

 

 

If you are subject to Federal law that requires overtime after 40 hours a week, you won't be able to use Options #2 or #4. These can only be used by organizations such as police departments that are allowed to average the work hours over a 2-week period.

 

If you don't have enough part-time employees or you don't have employees from another department to cover the 8-hour gap in coverage every week, you'll won't be able to use Options #2 or #3. You'll either need a 5-crew schedule (see Option #1), a schedule with 11.5-hour shifts (see Option #4), or a crewless schedule that is custom-designed around your staff size.

 

Let's do a quick cost comparison of 4-crew schedules vs. 5-crew schedules:

  • 4 crews * 40 hours/week * 1.4 benefit loading cost  +  4 crews * 4 hours of OT pay/week = 240 hours of pay/week
  • 5 crews * 36-hours/week * 1.4 benefit loading cost = 252 hours of pay/week

If you already have enough staff to create a 5-crew schedule, here's a way to save money. Keep the OT in the schedule and use your extra capacity to build relief coverage into the schedule to cover absences. Similar to Option #1, you would have a 5-week schedule that averages 42 hours a week. The difference is that the 5th week of the schedule would be devoted to relief coverage.

 

Doing this would shift the OT from outside the schedule to inside the schedule. When the overtime is outside the schedule, it requires volunteers or forced / mandated overtime. When it's inside the schedule, it is shared equally by the entire staff. In many cases, the total overtime is less. You can read more about this here: https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=you-can-t-eliminate-overtime-but-you-might-be-able-to-reduce-it.

 

We sell packages of 12-hour shifts for $199 apiece. One packages has 10 options with only fixed shifts and the other has 10 options with only rotating shifts. These all average 42 hours a week. You can read more about it here:  https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Schedule_Examples.

 

If you need help designing a 12-hour schedule with no overtime (e.g., to match your pay week or to accommodate a few part-time employees), please fill out this form:  https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/21.html

Eddie Perez says:
May 7th, 2016 at 3:29 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

Hi Bruce, this is kind of a last ditch effort but we, as a group, are being forced to give up our 12hr schedule and moved over to the three shifts of 8hrs in order to maintain 24/7 coverage and keep a 40 hour work week. Our management got dinged by the DOL, even though we had written agreements to work the 12hr shift, which was great for the amount of time off afforded, and is now making us switch. They gave us the option of creating our own so long as it was easy to schedule for payroll. I am desperately hoping you might have a viable solution for us.

We have 10 full-time employees, 2 people working 12 hr shifts, 6a-6p, 2 working nights, 6p-6a and one 12-midnight person covering lunches and breaks across both shifts. According to the DOL our work week is mandated to start at midnight on Sunday and ends 11:59 pm Saturday. We need to keep at least 2 people on at all times and maximum of 3. It can never be four or more(we don't have the equipment to have more than three at our call center) and we can never just have one all the while keeping the 40hrs per employee per week. We have two part-time people that also help cover time off and sick calls. 

Is there anything you can suggest that might help us? Any ideas would be greatly appreciated

jennifer says:
June 1st, 2016 at 5:06 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

It looks like if I need 9 staff per shift 24/7 in you 1st example I would have an overlapping weekend shift. Would it be feasable to let staff work 3 weekend shifts instead of the current 4 weekend shifts to prevent overlapping on the weekend.  24 nurses per shift, 13 holidays/year, 9-14 vacation hours per month depending on years of service. Does this look right? I am trying to let staff have more time off on the weekends and make it fair for everyone.  We are currently working 7/12's will be changing to 6 /12's inSeptember. Hiring 25% more staff. 

Derrick Preston says:
June 20th, 2016 at 12:25 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

Hi I work in the steel industry. I am looking for help creating a 3 crew 5 days a week 24 hr coverage that has no ovetime.  We shut down Thursday night/ Friday morning.  We are on days nights afternoons 8 hrs and it is a horrible shift for families and sleep patterns.  I am wondering if a combination of 10 hr days and nights with 12 hrs days and nights is there a way for the needed coverage.  We were working a 3 crew shift that went DD 1day off  NN 4 off then DDD 2 off thenow NNN 4 off but there is 8 hrs ot with that rotation. Can anyone help???

June 20th, 2016 at 1:49 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

Derrick,

 

3 crew schedules for 24/7 average 56 hours a week. 4 crew schedules for 24/7 average 42 hours a week. You would need a 5-crew schedule with 12s or a 6-crew schedule with 10s to avoid OT. My question is WHY? People think that avoiding overtime will save money, when it usually means hiring more staff. More staff is much more costly, especially when you add in the cost of benefits (vacation, holidays, insurance, etc.).

 

If you still insist on avoiding OT in the schedule, you need to expand the number of crews rather than reducing the number of crews. There are 168 hours in a week (24 x 7 = 168). Divide this by the number of crews to determine the average hours per week. With 10-hour shifts there are 210 hours in the week (30 x 7 = 210). That's why 10-hour schedules require more than 5 crews to avoid OT.

 

Bruce

CCT says:
June 26th, 2016 at 11:48 am   starstarstarstarstar      

I work in an ICU where we are trying to get 24/7 coverage for our Critical Care techs, we currently have 5 CCT's and have a horrible time finding a schedule that doesn't use rotating schedules

Jeff says:
July 20th, 2016 at 6:32 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

Looking for some input in a schedule.   Staff want a fast 12 (2days 2 nights) and 4 off.   8 teams needing 24 hr. coverage.    Employer now only wants to average 40 hours a week  not 42.    They are willing to look at options of working one shift shorter every couple weeks.

There are part time employees available to fill in the gaps.

The other thing is they want it to fit into a 46 week schedule.   They are open to having a fee of those weeks being different if need be.   This may sound confusing but wondering about its feasibility?

Thanks,

Jeff

Carwyn says:
February 23rd, 2017 at 3:38 am   starstarstarstarstar      

Hi 

 

I need a roster to cover following scenario

 

- 10 Shift workers

- 12hr shifts (Days & Nights)

- must always have 2 x dayworkers on and 2 x nightshifts workers on at a time.

- No more than 2 nightshifts in a row

- 76hr fortnight i.e. 152 hrs over 28 days

- Breaks are paid  so included in 76hr fortnight

- no more than 4 dayshifts in a row

= try to share weekends across all staff (penanlty rates)

 

Really need your help happy to have couple of 8hr dayshift 

Thomas says:
February 25th, 2017 at 11:19 am   starstarstarstarstar      

I am restructuring our facility to get away from eight hour shifts and giving the employees more time off while cutting overtime out. Would working 3 twelve hour shifts during the week and rotating a group every other Sunday be legal. It would result in 36 hours + 44 hours to reach 80 on a bi weekly pay scale. 

February 25th, 2017 at 11:52 am   starstarstarstarstar      
Thomas,
 
I can't comment on the legality of anything, but I can comment on your proposed approach:
 
1. Coverage. Limiting the employee work hours to 40 per week, whether it's with 8s or 12s, will result in an 8-hour gap in coverage every week. Most 24/7 schedules use 4 crews. If they work 40 hours a week, that's 160 hours of coverage (4 * 40 = 160). The problem is there are 168 hours in a week (7 * 24 = 168). Closing the gap will require hiring part-time employees or full-time employees. Either way, it's probably going to cost more than the overtime needed to close the gap.

2. Overtime. Even though you are averageing 40 hours a week, there will still be overtime pay for the 44-hour week. That's required by Federal overtime laws. The only exception would be if you are in law enforcement and can average the work hours over a 2-week period. The real question I have is, "Why do you want to cut overtime out?" If it's to save money, remember that it will cost you extra to close the 8-hour gap in coverage. If you are having a problem with too much overtime, it's probably because of absences. That's an entirely separate issue from overtime in the schedule itself.
 

Hope this helps.

 
 
Kevin says:
August 1st, 2017 at 11:56 am   starstarstarstarstar      

Hi

I am looking for a roster that has to be 36 hours per week 12 hour shifts

We dont want to work say 2 days on then 2 night off.

We want to try and do our 36hours in one hit and have plenty of time off

Hope you can assist in this matter

Name * 
Email * 
Rate This Post  
Spam Protection