Layer 3

 

Custom-Designed Employee Work Schedules

 

clock-circular-outline 8:00am - 5:00pm (Pacific Time Zone), Mon-Fri  

Blog

12-Hour Shift Schedules with No Overtime
July 3rd, 2013 at 10:37 am   starstarstarstarstar      

I've written several articles about 12-hour shift schedules in 24/7 operations. Here are links to the most popular ones:

  1. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/12-Hour_Shifts
     
  2. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=12-hour-shifts-in-smaller-companies
     
  3. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=matching-12-hour-shifts-to-your-workload-distribution
     
  4. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=covering-absences-on-a-12-hour-shift-schedule

  5. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=are-12-hour-shifts-too-long
     

I also sell 2 packages with 10 different options: one with only 12-hour fixed shifts and another with only 12-hour rotating shifts. You can read more about this here:  Schedule Examples

 

Most 12-hour shift schedules for 24/7 coverage use 4 crews. When you divide the hours in a week (168) by 4 crews, you get a average of 42 hours/week. With 12-hour shifts, this will require half the work weeks to be 36 hours (three 12-hour shifts) and half to be 48 hours (four 12-hour shifts). 

In many organizations, especially public agencies, avoiding overtime is a high priority. They view overtime as evil or an unnecessary expense. I have repeatedly tried to argue the fallacy of this belief, yet I continue to get requests for 12-hour schedules with no overtime in them. Here are 2 articles on this topic:

  1. http://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Overtime_Issues
  2. https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=why-eliminating-overtime-in-24-7-schedules-can-be-costly

Reducing the hours of work to 40 or less a week will result in gaps in the coverage and will require additional personnel to fill the gaps. In most cases, this is more expensive than simply keeping overtime in the schedule. In addition to higher costs, this will also require other sacrifices as seen in the following four approaches to eliminating overtime in 12-hour schedules for 24/7 coverage. 

 

Here is a key to the symbols used in the schedules below:


D12 = 12-hour day shift

N12 = 12-hour night shift

d8 = 8-hour day shift

n8 = 8-hour night shift

d4 = 4-hour day shift

a4 = 4-hour afternoon shift

e4 = 4-hour evening shift

n4 = 4-hour night shift


Here is how the schedules work. When the schedule first starts, the crews are assigned to specific weeks in the cycle. Crew A is assigned to start in Week 1, Crew B is assigned to start in Week 2, and so on. At the end of each week, the crews rotate down to the next week in the cycle. Crew A moves to Week 2, Crew B moves to Week 3, etc. When a crew completes the last week, they rotate up to Week 1. 

 

 

1. Eliminate the 48-hour work weeks. This sounds simple enough. Just change all the 48-hour work weeks to 36 hours by eliminating one of the shifts. To maintain the same coverage, this will require 5 crews (a 25% increase in headcount), rotating shifts, and a 4-hour pay cut for all employees. (Note that with fixed shifts, this would require 6 crews). There will also be one shift with double coverage (in the example below, it's the Friday day shift). Here's one example of a 5-crew schedule:

 

Crew / Week Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
A / Week 1 - - - - D12 D12 D12     36
B / Week 2 D12 - - D12 D12 - -     36
C / Week 3 - D12 D12 - - - N12     36
D / Week 4 N12 - - - N12 N12 -     36
E / Week 5 - N12 N12 N12 - - -     36
               Average

    36

 


2. Include an 8-hour shift. If you devote one day a week to 8-hour shifts and give one of the three 8-hour shifts to employees who are outside the group (e.g., part-time employees), the remaining four crews would average 40 hours a week. You would have to use a 12-hour work pattern in which the 36-hour weeks and 48-hour weeks are staggered and you would have to be able to average the work hours over a 2-week period (most companies can't do this because of overtime laws). In the sample shown below, the 8-hour afternoon shift on Wednesday would have to be given to employees who are not part of the four crews. That uncovered shift is not shown in the table below.


 

  Crew / Week  Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
  A / Week 1   - D12 d8 - - D12 D12     44
  B / Week 2   D12 - - D12 D12 - -     36
  C / Week 3   - N12 n8 - - N12 N12     44
  D / Week 4   N12 - - N12 N12 - -     36
              Average     40


3. Include a 4-hour shift. If you devote one day a week to 4-hour shifts and give two 4-hour shifts (or one 8-hour shift) to employees who are outside the group, the remaining four crews would average 40 hours a week. This does not require the averaging of pay over a 2-week period or a pattern with staggered 36 and 48-hour weeks. In the sample shown below, there is an 8-hour gap in coverage on Wednesday that would have to be given to part-time employees or someone outside the four crews. That uncovered shift is not shown in the table below.

 


  Crew / Week  Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
  A / Week 1  - D12 d4 - - D12 D12     40
  B / Week 2  D12 - a4 D12 D12 - -     40
  C / Week 3  - N12 n4 - - N12 N12     40
  D / Week 4  N12 - e4 N12 N12 - -     40
              Average     40

 

4. Reduce the work days to 11.5 hours. If you include a 30-minute unpaid meal break in the 12-hour shift, you only have to pay employees for 11.5 hours. You would have to adopt a 12-hour shift pattern in which the 48-hour weeks and 36-hour weeks were staggered. This won't completely eliminate the overtime, and you would have to be able to average the work hours over a 2-week period. An example is shown below:

 

  Crew / Week  Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun   Hours
  A / Week 1  - D11.5 D11.5 - - D11.5 D11.5     46
  B / Week 2  D11.5 - - D11.5 D11.5 - -     34.5
  C / Week 3  - N11.5 N11.5 - - N11.5 N11.5     46
  D / Week 4  N11.5 - - N11.5 N11.5 - -     34.5
              Average     40.25

 

 

If you are subject to Federal law that requires overtime after 40 hours a week, you won't be able to use Options #2 or #4. These can only be used by organizations such as police departments that are allowed to average the work hours over a 2-week period.

 

If you don't have enough part-time employees or you don't have employees from another department to cover the 8-hour gap in coverage every week, you'll won't be able to use Options #2 or #3. You'll either need a 5-crew schedule (see Option #1), a schedule with 11.5-hour shifts (see Option #4), or a crewless schedule that is custom-designed around your staff size.

 

Let's do a quick cost comparison of 4-crew schedules vs. 5-crew schedules:

  • 4 crews * 40 hours/week * 1.4 benefit loading cost  +  4 crews * 4 hours of OT pay/week = 240 hours of pay/week
  • 5 crews * 36-hours/week * 1.4 benefit loading cost = 252 hours of pay/week

If you already have enough staff to create a 5-crew schedule, here's a way to save money. Keep the OT in the schedule and use your extra capacity to build relief coverage into the schedule to cover absences. Similar to Option #1, you would have a 5-week schedule that averages 42 hours a week. The difference is that the 5th week of the schedule would be devoted to relief coverage.

 

Doing this would shift the OT from outside the schedule to inside the schedule. When the overtime is outside the schedule, it requires volunteers or forced / mandated overtime. When it's inside the schedule, it is shared equally by the entire staff. In many cases, the total overtime is less. You can read more about this here: https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Blog?m8:post=you-can-t-eliminate-overtime-but-you-might-be-able-to-reduce-it.

 

We sell packages of 12-hour shifts for $199 apiece. One packages has 10 options with only fixed shifts and the other has 10 options with only rotating shifts. These all average 42 hours a week. You can read more about it here:  https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/Schedule_Examples.

 

If you need help designing a 12-hour schedule with no overtime (e.g., to match your pay week or to accommodate a few part-time employees), please fill out this form:  https://www.shift-schedule-design.com/21.html

Joseph Arlington says:
October 30th, 2013 at 2:49 am   starstarstarstarstar      

      Bruce thank you so much.  I really hope they wake up and realize that their squabbling over the small amouth of money is stupid.  What are they saving? and  Really is it that much.    of a saving? concidering the problems it would stur up. Thanks again. Joe.

Black Cat says:
July 25th, 2014 at 10:55 am   starstarstarstarstar      

Scumbag

July 28th, 2014 at 2:59 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

Black Cat,

I take it from your comment that you disagree with my position on this topic. That's fair. It's just my opinion. However, I wish you would have stated why you disagree rather than resorting to name calling. I'm sure there are other people who would like to hear your opinion.

Although I'm not a fan of 12-hour schedules with no overtime in them, I just finished designing one. The organization had 11 employees working rotating shifts. They needed 3-person coverage on the weekday day shift and 2-person coverage at all other times. With 36-hour work weeks, this was a perfect match. I created an 11-week schedule that has three 7-8 day breaks in it. Using 36-hour work weeks is more expensive for the organization, but the employees LOVE this schedule. 36-hour work weeks are widely used in the healthcare industry.

October 30th, 2014 at 6:40 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

Erika,

To avoid OT in the schedule, even though I don't recommend doing this, you can either use approaches #2 or #3 in the original post. You could also use all 8-hour shifts, as long as the shifts rotate. Each of these would require a 9-week schedule. If you would like me to design the actual schedules, I would have to charge for my time. Please contact me if you need more than this.

Bruce

Griffin says:
January 8th, 2015 at 3:13 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

A more simple solution.  Make the employees exempt and salaried then you don't have to worry about overtime.  Nobody from DOL ever checks up on these kind of changes so the odds of getting hurt if the workers are non really exempt is slim to none.

January 8th, 2015 at 9:47 pm   starstarstarstarstar      

I'm sorry, but I can't condone something that is illegal. I know there are 20 questions that determine whether someone is salaried or not. I also know that many large companies received huge fines for incorrectly classifying employees to avoid overtime payments. This still doesn't address my key point: why bother to get rid of the overtime. It is less expensive than the alternatives, it has no risk, and the employees appreciate the extra pay.

Dan says:
November 29th, 2022 at 1:57 pm         

They don't like overtime because it exposes and invalidates Diversity Equity and Inclusion principles. Men are the ones willing to do more OT and then all it takes is 1 disgruntled female employee with no understanding of this, who now sees a man with the same position making more money. They will blame sexism and everyone will support them, leaving the business to do damage control. They want to maintain the illusion of sexism because it benefits them socially and reduces competition.

Sean McCarthy says:
January 25th, 2015 at 11:10 am   starstarstarstarstar      

My company recently decided to take us off an 8 hour rotating shift schedule to get rid of the built in 8hrs per 4 weeks we all recieved. There are 10 of us total working in the control room. They need coverage for (4) on the day shift (3) on the afternoon shift and (2) overnight. That would leave (1) outside those constraints. They came up with a pretty crazy scheme and most of us work one straight shift with a day of coverage on another shift here or there, 2 guys are over the place shift wise. Needless to say we all hate it and were tasked with finding a better way to counter what they have proposed. Any thoughts on this would be appreciated!

January 25th, 2015 at 11:42 am   starstarstarstarstar      

Sean, If you work 24/7, it takes at least 12.6 people working an average of 40 hours a week to provide the coverage you described. Your staff of 10 people would have to work an average of 50.4 hours a week. It sounds like management is trying to solve a staffing/coverage problem with a new schedule. That will only make things worse. If I have misunderstood something about your situation, please send me an email to clarify.

Crazy says:
April 28th, 2016 at 1:48 am   starstarstarstarstar      

I have to create a 12 hours shift schedule for 6 people working two man per shift 24/7. for a 40 hour week which means they will work three days for 12 hours then a4 hours on another day equals 40 hours. hours. 

 

Please help me creat this schedule

April 28th, 2016 at 10:21 am   starstarstarstarstar      
Crazy: If I understand you correctly, you need 2-person coverage on a 24/7 basis. This would require at least 8 people working an average of 42 hours a week. Trying to do this with only 6 people and limiting the hours to 40 per week will result in a number of gaps in the coverage. If I have misunderstood something please let me know. Otherwise, what you are asking for is impossible.
Name * 
Email * 
Rate This Post  
Spam Protection